Michael Vick Doesn't Deserve A Second Chance

The Axiom Of Responsibility
Individuals Demonstrate Valid Behavior
By Taking Responsibility
For Themselves And Their Children


"Once the NFL's highest-paid player" as quarterback for the Atlanta Falcons, Michael Vick was recently released after "[serving] 18 months of a 23-month sentence in federal prison" for "conspiracy and running a dog-fighting ring that brutally killed and tortured canines." ("Michael Vick's Second Chance With the Eagles; Now What?")

What is life like now for Vick, "a man who hanged dogs from trees, electrocuted them with jumper cables, held them underwater until they drowned in his swimming pool, and even threw his own family dogs into the fighting pit to be torn to shreds while he laughed"? The Philadelphia Eagles signed him to a "$1.6 million one-year deal with the team, with an option for a second year." Not only will he "be able to participate in team practices, meetings and two pre-season games," but there is also the possibility that on "week six of the regular season," he will become "eligible for full reinstatement."

With this decision, the Eagles have made a huge mistake that negatively affects our entire society: Like it or not, because of their high profile playing football and advertising products, professional football players are seen as role models, as well as representatives of America and its culture. Vick does not deserve this honor in any way, shape, or form, and by signing him, the Eagles have put a disgrace to the sport (and humankind) in one of their team's most important positions.

Being a highly-paid quarterback in the NFL really is an honor: Given the caliber of talent, ability, and level of sportsmanship in the NFL, a spot at the top of the pay scale is quite an honor. Further, the position of quarterback carries the responsibility of team leadership, also an honor. Sadly, many of America's professional athletes do not appreciate the honor of their positions, conducting themselves, both on and off the field, in a manner unworthy of respect. It is time America held her professional athletes responsible for their actions, and it is time these athletes' behavior reflected the privilege of their prominent positions.

In his attempt to win back public favor, Michael Vick has conducted a number of interviews, including one last Sunday night on 60 Minutes. During these interviews, Vick repeats various versions of statements like, "I know I made mistakes and have done some terrible things and made a horrible mistake. [. . .] And, now, I want to be a part of the solution and not the problem." Unfortunately for Vick, these assertions come off as completely unbelievable. His "apologies" appear forced, regurgitated, and extremely disingenuous, as though he isn't sorry for the disgusting acts he has committed, but rather that he got caught.

According to Magna Sententia, we are all responsible for our behavior and must face the consequences of our choices. Because he completed his prison term, Michael Vick is a free man who should be allowed to earn a living, but not in a public position that influences society and represents our country.


Anna and Ellie Sherise
Creators of Magna Sententia
Authors of Magna Sententia: The Logical Cure for Our Society